NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- The endless speculation over the past two weeks about Jameis Winston's future with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers won’t be quieted after Sunday's sloppy loss to the Tennessee Titans, a game in which he threw two interceptions and lost two fumbles, with two of his turnovers setting up Titans touchdowns.
“Everyone is going to say, 'Jameis threw interceptions,'" Bucs coach Bruce Arians said. “Jameis did not throw one damn interception that was his fault. His receivers let him down today."
Arians has a point, although he’s beginning to sound like a broken record with this -- a line we've heard since the summer.
On Winston’s second pick, thrown from his own 36-yard line with :26 left and down 27-23, wide receiver Breshad Perriman went upfield when Winston expected him to break inside.
There was also a botched QB-center exchange with Ryan Jensen at the Tampa Bay 16-yard line on the Bucs’ second possession. Jensen snapped the ball while Winston was calling out protections at the line of scrimmage and not looking for the snap -- that’s on the center, not Winston.
The Harold Landry sack-fumble in the fourth quarter was completely on left tackle Donovan Smith, who allowed Landry to blow by him along the backside and get a hand on Winston as he was winding up.
But you can’t ignore the interception on a pass intended for wide receiver Chris Godwin -- who has one of the league’s best catch percentages despite the high volume of throws his way -- coming on an in-route with Malcolm Butler swooping in at the Tampa Bay 29. That ball was overthrown.
You also can’t ignore the three stalled trips to the red zone, with drives ending at the 4-, 25- and 5-yard lines, resulting in field goals instead of touchdowns. In the second quarter, they went just 45 yards in 16 plays and settled for a 48-yard field goal.
Sure, offensive coordinator Byron Leftwich’s questionable playcalling and use of personnel will be scrutinized over the next several days -- heavily relying on Perriman and running back Dare Ogunbowale in key scoring situations despite them doing little to earn that level of trust. Tampa's offense features some of the most dynamic receiving weapons in the league in Godwin, Mike Evans and Cameron Brate (O.J. Howard missed the game with a hamstring injury), so this should work. With Winston coming off a five-interception performance in London in Week 6 and back-to-back divisional losses, he needed to deliver and couldn’t.
Winston did connect with Evans on a beautiful, 46-yard deep pass, followed by a 9-yard touchdown strike -- the first of two for Evans on the day. Those kinds of plays offer some hope, but not enough when a fifth-year starter has been outplayed by Daniel Jones, Teddy Bridgewater, Kyle Allen and now Ryan Tannehill. The Bucs are sitting at 2-5 nearing the halfway point of the season.
While Winston can’t be blamed for the defense allowing the Titans to trek 90 yards on 12 plays late in the fourth quarter, or a young secondary that, as Arians put it, “Needs to get their head out of their asses,” two of this offense's turnovers set up Titans touchdowns and he did nothing to quiet the skeptics doubting his ability to lead in key moments.
A franchise quarterback must shoulder the load, when everything around him fails, even if it goes against what Arians has been preaching to him since Day 1, telling him, "You don’t have to try to be Superman. Let those around you help you." It’s about having the right initiative.
If there are communication issues with receivers and the offensive line, Winston has to step in to get everyone on the same page. These communication issues will only be magnified in one of the noisiest stadiums in the league next week in Seattle, regardless of Arians’ dazzling 4-1 record there as a visiting coach.
Imagine if Arians’ former star pupil Andrew Luck was given a free pass for all of Indianapolis’ offensive line failures during his tenure. He threw that city onto his back, paying dearly for it from a physical standpoint, but still delivering on the expectations of him when he wasn't in the training room.
Winston's Titans counterpart, Marcus Mariota, wasn't given excuses for the poor play of his offensive line, despite being tied with Winston for most sacks of QBs in the league and despite the constant coaching turnover he's had to endure. He was still benched and watched Sunday's game from the sideline.
As a quarterback, sometimes you’re all you’ve got.
And right now, nearing the halfway point of the season, the Bucs have got more questions than answers when it comes to Winston.