<
        >

          NFL Nation

          Grading the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl 50

          play
          Dilfer: The Panthers did not lose because of Cam Newton (1:37)

          Trent Dilfer evaluates the effort of Cam Newton and the Panthers' offense in their loss to the Broncos, saying Newton was not the primary reason for the loss. (1:37)

          SANTA CLARA, Calif. -- The Carolina Panthers lost to the Denver Broncos 24-10 in Super Bowl 50. Here’s a report card of the Panthers' performance:

          PASSING OFFENSE: C-minus

          Cam Newton looked shaky early, with only 36 yards passing with 1 minute, 22 seconds to go in the first half. Still, there were numerous dropped passes, for with every acrobatic grab, there were seemingly butterfingers to follow. The strip-sack of Newton in the first quarter and fumble recovery in the end zone proved to be the difference.

          RUSHING OFFENSE: C-minus

          Jonathan Stewart injured a foot early and became a non-factor, even as his over-the-pile leap for a touchdown reminded many of Marcus Allen. Mike Tolbert had a costly fumble, and against the Broncos’ stout front, the run game could not gain traction.

          PASSING DEFENSE: C

          Defensive end Kony Ealy had a one-handed interception and a 19-yard return as the Panthers' secondary limited Peyton Manning to 141 yards passing.

          RUSHING DEFENSE: C-minus

          The Panthers could not stop C.J. Anderson when it mattered most, with Anderson breaking off a key 34-yard run in the first half. Anderson finished with 90 yards rushing on 23 carries.

          SPECIAL TEAMS: D

          Place-kicker Graham Gano missed a 44-yard field goal attempt in the third quarter that would have pulled the Panthers within three points. It appeared as though Aqib Talib was in the neutral zone on the snap, though no flag was thrown.

          COACHING: C-minus

          Panthers coach Ron Rivera punted while trailing by two touchdowns with two minutes to play and his team’s back in the end zone. Strange? The Panthers simply had no answer for the Denver defense in general, Von Miller in particular.