| 1970 | Jan. 3, 1971 | Baltimore 27, Oakland 17 |
| 1971 | Jan. 2, 1972 | Miami 21, Baltimore 0 |
| 1972 | Dec. 31, 1972 | Miami 21, Pittsburgh 17 |
| 1973 | Dec. 30, 1973 | Miami 27, Oakland 10 |
| 1974 | Dec. 29, 1974 | Pittsburgh 24, Oakland 17 |
| 1975 | Jan. 4, 1976 | Pittsburgh 16, Oakland 10 |
| 1976 | Dec. 26, 1976 | Oakland 24, Pittsburgh 7 |
| 1977 | Jan. 1, 1978 | Denver 20, Oakland 17 |
| 1978 | Jan. 7, 1979 | Pittsburgh 34, Houston 5 |
| 1979 | Jan. 6, 1980 | Pittsburgh 27, Houston 13 |
| 1980 | Jan. 11, 1981 | Oakland 34, San Diego 27 |
| 1981 | Jan. 10, 1982 | Cincinnati 27, San Diego 7 |
| 1982 | Jan. 23, 1983 | Miami 14, N.Y. Jets 0 |
| 1983 | Jan. 8, 1984 | L.A. Raiders 30, Seattle 14 |
| 1984 | Jan. 6, 1985 | Miami 45, Pittsburgh 28 |
| 1985 | Jan. 12, 1986 | New England 31, Miami 14 |
| 1986 | Jan. 11, 1987 | Denver 23, Cleveland 20 * |
| 1987 | Jan. 17, 1988 | Denver 38, Cleveland 33 |
| 1988 | Jan. 8, 1989 | Cincinnati 21, Buffalo 10 |
| 1989 | Jan. 14, 1990 | Denver 37, Cleveland 21 |
| 1990 | Jan. 20, 1991 | Buffalo 51, L.A. Raiders 3 |
| 1991 | Jan. 12, 1992 | Buffalo 10, Denver 7 |
| 1992 | Jan. 17, 1993 | Buffalo 29, Miami 10 |
| 1993 | Jan. 23, 1994 | Buffalo 30, Kansas City 13 |
| 1994 | Jan. 15, 1995 | San Diego 17, Pittsburgh 13 |
| 1995 | Jan. 14, 1996 | Pittsburgh 20, Indianapolis 16 |
| 1996 | Jan. 12, 1997 | New England 20, Jacksonville 6 |
| 1997 | Jan. 11, 1998 | Denver 24, Pittsburgh 21 |
| 1998 | Jan. 17, 1999 | Denver 23, N.Y. Jets 10 |
| 1999 | Jan. 23, 2000 | Tennessee 33, Jacksonville 14 |
| 2000 | Jan. 14, 2001 | Baltimore 16, Oakland 3 |
| 2001 | Jan. 27, 2002 | New England 24, Pittsburgh 17 |
| 2002 | Jan. 19, 2003 | Oakland 41, Tennessee 24 |
| 2003 | Jan. 18, 2004 | New England 24, Indianapolis 14 |
| 2004 | Jan. 23, 2005 | New England 41, Pittsburgh 27 |
| 2005 | Jan. 22, 2006 | Pittsburgh 34, Denver 17 |
| 2006 | Jan. 21, 2007 | Indianapolis 38, New England 34 |
| 2007 | Jan. 20, 2008 | New England 21, San Diego 12 |
| 2008 | Jan. 18, 2009 | Pittsburgh 23, Baltimore 14 |
| 2009 | Jan. 24, 2010 | Indianapolis 30, N.Y. Jets 17 |
| 2010 | Jan. 23, 2011 | Pittsburgh 24, N.Y. Jets 19 |
| 2011 | Jan. 22, 2012 | New England 23, Baltimore 20 |
| 2012 | Jan. 20, 2013 | Baltimore 28, New England 13 |
| 2013 | Jan. 19, 2014 | Denver 26, New England 16 |
| 2014 | Jan. 18, 2015 | New England 45, Indianapolis 7 |
| 2015 | Jan. 24, 2016 | Denver 20, New England 18 |
