2009 -- x-Albert Pujols, St. Louis
2008 -- Albert Pujols, St. Louis
2007 -- Jimmy Rollins, Philadelphia
2006 -- Ryan Howard, Philadelphia
2005 -- Albert Pujols, St. Louis
2004 -- Barry Bonds, San Francisco
2003 -- Barry Bonds, San Francisco
2002 -- x-Barry Bonds, San Francisco
2001 -- Barry Bonds, San Francisco
2000 -- Jeff Kent, San Francisco
1999 -- Chipper Jones, Atlanta
1998 -- Sammy Sosa, Chicago
1997 -- Larry Walker, Colorado
1996 -- x-Ken Caminiti, San Diego
1995 -- Barry Larkin, Cincinnati
1994 -- x-Jeff Bagwell, Houston
1993 -- Barry Bonds, San Francisco
1992 -- Barry Bonds, Pittsburgh
1991 -- Terry Pendleton, Atlanta
1990 -- Barry Bonds, Pittsburgh
1989 -- Kevin Mitchell, San Francisco
1988 -- Kirk Gibson, Los Angeles
1987 -- Andre Dawson, Chicago
1986 -- Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia
1985 -- Willie McGee, St. Louis
1984 -- Ryne Sandberg, Chicago
1983 -- Dale Murphy, Atlanta
1982 -- Dale Murphy, Atlanta
1981 -- Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia
1980 -- x-Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia
1979 -- Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh, and Keith Hernandez, St. Louis
1978 -- Dave Parker, Pittsburgh
1977 -- George Foster, Cincinnati
1976 -- Joe Morgan, Cincinnati
1975 -- Joe Morgan, Cincinnati
1974 -- Steve Garvey, Los Angeles
1973 -- Pete Rose, Cincinnati
1972 -- Johnny Bench, Cincinnati
1971 -- Joe Torre, St. Louis
1970 -- Johnny Bench, Cincinnati
1969 -- Willie McCovey, San Francisco
1968 -- Bob Gibson, St. Louis
1967 -- x-Orlando Cepeda, St. Louis
1966 -- Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh
1965 -- Willie Mays, San Francisco
1964 -- Ken Boyer, St. Louis
1963 -- Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles
1962 -- Maury Wills, Los Angeles
1961 -- Frank Robinson, Cincinnati
1960 -- Dick Groat, Pittsburgh
1959 -- Ernie Banks, Chicago
1958 -- Ernie Banks, Chicago
1957 -- Hank Aaron, Milwaukee
1956 -- Don Newcombe, Brooklyn
1955 -- Roy Campanella, Brooklyn
1954 -- Willie Mays, New York
1953 -- Roy Campanella, Brooklyn
1952 -- Hank Sauer, Chicago
1951 -- Roy Campanella, Brooklyn
1950 -- Jim Konstanty, Philadelphia
1949 -- Jackie Robinson, Brooklyn
1948 -- Stan Musial, St. Louis
1947 -- Bob Elliott, Boston
1946 -- Stan Musial, St. Louis
1945 -- Phil Cavarretta, Chicago
1944 -- Marty Marion, St. Louis
1943 -- Stan Musial, St. Louis
1942 -- Mort Cooper, St. Louis
1941 -- Dolph Camilli, Brooklyn
1940 -- Frank McCormick, Cincinnati
1939 -- Bucky Walters, Cincinnati
1938 -- Ernie Lombardi, Cincinnati
1937 -- Joe Medwick, St. Louis
1936 -- Carl Hubbell, New York
1935 -- Gabby Hartnett, Chicago
1934 -- Dizzy Dean, St. Louis
1933 -- Carl Hubbell, New York
1932 -- Chuck Klein, Philadelphia
1931 -- Frank Frisch, St. Louis
x-unanimous selection.